How We Ask Matters: A Scoping Review of Visual and Auditory Technologies for Patient-Reported Measures.
Researchers
Jessica Nikolovski, Hannah Potts, Elle Papamichos, Tahlia Nikolovski, Kyumin Jang, Leslie White, Claire Treadgold, Rachael L Morton, Mandie Foster, Ann Dadich
Abstract
Patient-reported measures (PRMs) are predominantly collected using paper-based or static electronic questionnaires, despite concerns these text-based formats may not be accessible for all patients. Visual, conversational, voice-enabled and gamified technologies offer alternative ways for patients to report their health and care experiences and may reduce barriers related to literacy, language, age, cognitive capacity, visual impairment and physical or mobility limitations. This scoping review identified these technologies and synthesised evidence on their acceptability, measurement performance, accessibility, equity and implementation. A systematic scoping review was conducted in accordance with Joanna Briggs Institute methodology and reported using PRISMA-ScR guidance. Six databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, Scopus, CINAHL and ACM Digital Library) were searched from January 2016 to May 2026. Eligible studies evaluated digital modalities for collecting PRMs beyond word-based paper or static electronic survey formats. Data were extracted about modality characteristics, accessibility features, usability, acceptability, feasibility, data quality, psychometric performance, implementation factors, interoperability and equity considerations. Equity was assessed using the PROGRESS-Plus framework, and findings were synthesised narratively. Forty publications reported 27 unique technologies. The identified technologies were mainly visual and auditory and fell into four broad categories: visual and pictorial, conversational and chatbot-based, voice-enabled and gamified. Thirteen protocols, conference abstracts and clinical trial registrations were identified and synthesised separately to characterise emerging developments in the field. Many technologies were explicitly designed to reduce barriers to participation related to literacy, communication, paediatric development, sensory, or cognitive abilities. Across studies, acceptability, usability and short-term feasibility were reported as positive. Overall, patients reported visual and auditory technologies were easier to understand, more engaging and less burdensome than text-based PRMs. Evidence supporting measurement performance was more limited. Several studies demonstrated psychometric equivalence or acceptable validity compared with text-based PRMs; however, robust evidence on reliability, responsiveness and cross-setting comparability remained scarce. Few studies evaluated implementation readiness, interoperability with health information systems, sustainability or long-term engagement. Equity assessment demonstrated greater attention to age, disability and paediatric developmental needs than to socioeconomic disadvantage, social capital, occupation or broader social determinants of digital participation. The question for the next generation of PRMs is no longer whether patients can complete a questionnaire. It is: can we create more opportunities to ensure all patients are heard? While visual and auditory technologies show promise for improving inclusivity and participation, evidence remains concentrated on usability rather than measurement performance, implementation and equity outcomes. Robust evaluation of psychometric properties, implementation readiness, accessibility and impacts on representation is needed before widespread adoption of visual and auditory technologies for PRM completion. Not applicable for this scoping review.Source: PubMed (PMID: 43034974)View Original on PubMed